De minimis curat lex: New Zealand law and the challenge of the very small

Authors

  • Colin Gavaghan
  • Jennifer Moore

Abstract

In 2010, the New Zealand Government commissioned a review on the ability of New Zealand’s regulatory systems to manage the potential health, safety and environmental risks posed by manufactured nanomaterials. While some of the gaps identified by this review are specific to New Zealand’s regulatory arrangements, other potential gaps are common to regulators in different jurisdictions. Scientific uncertainties about hazard, human exposure, nano-toxicity and risk persist. Regulators charged with protecting public health face challenges due to these scientific gaps. Deciding what burden and standard of proof is most appropriate in the face of uncertain scientific evidence is a common challenge. 

In light of this particular shared regulatory challenge, this article examines New Zealand’s regulatory framework for hazardous substances. It will consider a range of potential regulatory challenges and ‘gaps’. Specifically, it will explore the uncertainty surrounding standard of proof, for example, in the designation of ‘hazardous’ in New Zealand’s Hazardous Substances and New Organisms Act 1996.  We will also explore the question of how ‘precautionary’ an approach should be adopted in relation to hazardous substances containing nanoparticles, using carbon nanotubes as a topical and paradigmatic case study. Regulatory enforcement and compliance issues are also examined. Like other jurisdictions, New Zealand is no stranger to the difficulties posed by regulatory notification requirements which are not adhered to and for which there are no mechanisms in place for monitoring compliance.    

Author Biographies

Colin Gavaghan

New Zealand Law Foundation Director in Emerging Technologies
Faculty of Law
University of Otago
Dunedin 9054
New Zealand

Jennifer Moore

Legal advisor to the New Zealand Law Commission. She is currently working on research about NZ's death certification system, including a first principles review of the Burials and Cremations Act and the relevant provisions from the Coroners Act 2006.

Downloads

Published

2011-11-08

Issue

Section

Refereed Articles